Toronto’s Sweetest Fall Tradition: The Annual Apple Pie Contest & Fundraiser Returns -

As the crisp air of November settles over Toronto, one event stands out as a warm and delicious celebration of community, creativity, and comfort food: the Annual Apple Pie Contest & Fundraiser. Hosted by the Trinity Bellwoods on Dundas BIA, this charming competition invites bakers from across the city to showcase their best apple pie recipes in a spirited contest that also supports a meaningful cause.

A Celebration of Pie and Purpose

Taking place on Saturday, November 8, 2025, from 1:00 PM to 3:00 PM, the contest will be held at the Collective Arts Toronto Taproom & Café, located at 777 Dundas Street West. This cozy venue, known for its craft beverages and vibrant art-forward atmosphere, provides the perfect backdrop for a fall afternoon filled with flaky crusts, spiced apples, and friendly competition.

The event is more than just a baking contest—it’s a fundraiser for St. Stephen’s Community House, a local organization that provides essential services to low-income families in Toronto. Every slice sold helps support programs that make a real difference in the lives of community members.

How the Contest Works

The contest is open to home bakers, professionals, and even past contestants from The Great Canadian Baking Show, making it a diverse and exciting showcase of talent. Participants pay a $10 entry fee, which goes directly to the fundraiser. Attendees can purchase slices of pie for $5 each, with all proceeds benefiting St. Stephen’s.

Judging is based on four key criteria:

Appearance
Crust
Filling
Overall Taste

A panel of culinary experts, including Jennifer Emilson and Michelle Pennock, will evaluate each pie. Emilson is known for her food photography and recipe development, while Pennock brings years of experience as a culinary director at Kraft Heinz Canada. Their discerning palates ensure that only the most delicious and well-crafted pies rise to the top.

*Photo credit: The Spruce Eats – Make Your Best Meal*

Prizes and Prestige

The stakes are sweet:

First Place: $200
Second Place: $100
Third Place: $50

Winners not only receive cash prizes but also earn bragging rights in Toronto’s growing community of amateur and professional bakers. The contest has become a beloved tradition, drawing repeat participants and enthusiastic newcomers alike.

Rules for Bakers

To maintain fairness and uphold the spirit of homemade baking, the contest has a few important rules:

Only apple pies are allowed—no other fruit or fillings.
Pies must be homemade, including the rolled pastry crust (single, double, or crumb top).
No store-bought fillings or crusts.
Pies must not require refrigeration.
Bakers must submit a list of ingredients (not shared publicly).
All pies must be delivered on disposable plates.

Pies are dropped off between 11:00 AM and 1:00 PM on the day of the event. Judging begins promptly at 1:00 PM, and the tasting and fundraising portion follows immediately after.

A Community-Driven Experience

The Annual Apple Pie Contest is more than just a culinary competition—it’s a celebration of local culture and community spirit. Organized by the Trinity Bellwoods on Dundas BIA, the event reflects the neighborhood’s commitment to fostering connection through food, art, and shared experiences.

The BIA has a history of supporting small businesses and community initiatives, and this contest is a shining example of how local organizations can bring people together in meaningful ways. Whether you’re a baker, a foodie, or simply someone who loves a good slice of pie, this event offers something for everyone.

Why Apple Pie?

Apple pie holds a special place in Canadian hearts. It’s a symbol of home, tradition, and seasonal abundance. With Ontario’s apple harvest peaking in the fall, November is the perfect time to celebrate this iconic dessert. The contest encourages bakers to get creative with spices, crust techniques, and presentation, while still honoring the classic flavors that make apple pie so beloved.

How to Attend

The event is open to the public, and no registration is required for attendees. Just show up at Collective Arts Toronto Taproom on November 8 and bring your appetite. Slices are sold on a first-come, first-served basis, so early arrival is recommended.

For bakers interested in competing, registration is available via Eventbrite. The deadline to register is November 6, and space is limited, so early sign-up is encouraged.

A Delicious Way to Give Back

In a city as diverse and dynamic as Toronto, events like the Apple Pie Contest remind us of the simple joys that bring people together. Baking a pie, sharing a slice, and supporting a local cause—these are the ingredients of a truly memorable afternoon.

Whether you’re entering the contest, volunteering, or just stopping by to enjoy the festivities, the Annual Apple Pie Contest & Fundraiser offers a warm and welcoming way to kick off November. It’s a celebration of flavor, generosity, and the power of community—one slice at a time.

Dive deeper into the city’s vibrant life! Get the latest updates, events, and Toronto news delivered straight to your inbox: subscribe to our newsletter today.